MLS# 100449946 – 303 Mcreynolds Street, Carthage, NC 28327

$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
Price: $430,900
Beds: 5
Baths: 2
Living Area SqFt: 3,609
Status: Active
Property Type: Single Family Residence
Lot Size Acres: 0.56
Lot Size SqFt: 24,394
Year Built: 1916
Neighborhood: Not In Subdivision
Days on Website: 361

Courtesy of Caroline Thomas Goodwin, Thomas Realty

Property Description

Seller is offering a $15,000 buyer concession/incentive with an acceptable offer. The Addison Spencer House exhibits details from the Craftsman style, combined with modest references to Colonial Revival and is a proud testament to Carthage’s rich architectural heritage. This 5 bedroom home commands attention with its grand presence and intricate exterior detailing; its gable-roofed, double-pile frame with broad shed dormer above three-bay-facade; recessed porch with paired slender tapered posts on brick piers. The rear wrap around deck overlooks the beautifully landscaped terraced yard. The interior boasts high ceilings, original hardwood floors, and meticulous craftsmanship curated to evoke the charm of the early 20th century. A large kitchen addition was added that boasts beautiful heart pine flooring, loads of custom cabinetry, granite tops, double ovens, built-in desk area and opens to a wonderful breakfast room overlooking the back deck. Just off the kitchen is a butlers pantry/mini bar loaded with built-ins that opens to a hidden laundry room. Underneath the home is a large walk-in/workshop area great for additional storage. Throughout its storied history, the Addison Spencer House has served as a beloved gathering place for generations. Make your appointment today.

$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage
$430,900 - 5Br/2Ba -  for Sale in Not In Subdivision, Carthage

Open House

  • Tour This Home
  • OR
    Request Information
  • Hidden
  • Hidden

Property Details and Features

  • Property Access
  • Road Type/Frontage: Public (City/Cty/St)
  • Appliances & Equipment
  • Built-In Microwave
  • Dishwasher
  • Washer
  • Refrigerator
  • Electric Cooktop
  • Dryer
  • Double Oven
  • Attic Information
  • Walk-In
  • Bathrooms
  • 2 total bathrooms
  • 2 full bathrooms
  • Bedrooms
  • 5 bedrooms
  • Building
  • Heated SqFt Range: 3500 – 3999
  • 3,609 heated sqft
  • Built in 1916
  • 2 stories
  • 9 rooms
  • Construction: Wood Frame
  • Porch/Balcony/Deck: Covered,Deck
  • Stories/Levels: One and One Half
  • Cooling
  • Heat Pump
  • Dining Room
  • Dining Room Type: Formal
  • Exterior Features
  • Exterior Finish: Wood Siding
  • Exterior Structures: Storage,Workshop
  • Fence
  • None
  • Fireplaces
  • 3+
  • Foundation
  • Combination
  • Water Features
  • Electric
  • Heating
  • Heat Pump
  • Interior Features
  • Kitchen Island
  • Workshop
  • Wet Bar
  • Walk-in Shower
  • Pantry
  • Master Downstairs
  • Laundry
  • Laundry Location: Laundry Room
  • Listing
  • Listed on 2024-06-12
  • Construction Type: Stick Built
  • List Price/SqFt: $119
  • Terms: Cash,Commercial
  • Location
  • County: Moore
  • Zip Code: 28327
  • Latitude: 35.348362
  • Longitude: -79.420012
  • Subdivision: Not In Subdivision
  • City Limits: Yes
  • Lot
  • 24,394 sqft lot
  • Lot Dimensions: 90×249.61x122x310
  • 0.56 acres
  • Parking
  • On Site
  • Possession
  • At Closing
  • Property
  • Zoning: R-HD
  • Roof
  • Composition
  • Schools
  • School District: Moore County Schools
  • Taxes
  • Tax Assessed Value: $265,250
  • Property Taxes: $2,314
  • City Tax Rate: 4881
  • Tax Year: 2023
  • Utilities
  • Sewer Available
  • Water Available

Property Map

$430,900 – 303 Mcreynolds Street, Carthage, NC 28327

Street View

Nearby Schools

Print Options

Select the items on the page that you would like to print. This "Print Options" block will not be printed.

Main Photo Main Details Property Description Property Features
Additional Photos Addtl Photos Size Location Map Schools

© 2025 Hive MLS

MLS LogoThe data relating to real estate on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Hive MLS, and is updated as of June 8, 2025 5:49AM. All information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change, or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor Thomas Realty shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon these data.